So after much research and consideration, locking into a BTO flat would be a good thing to do because of the following reasons:
a. Inflation over 4 years.
The 3 room flat that I’m looking at now has an indicative price of about $175,000. That’s for BTO 2012 March launch which will be ready in 3 years. Assuming that we both decide to purchase a similar flat 3 years later, the price would be subjected to an inflation of conservative rate of about 2.6% p.a (based of the avg of inflation over the last 5 years), which will be $189,000, an additional of $14,000 at least.
The point here is yes, although every year theres inflation. But year on year it’ll be more expensive to buy a flat, so might as well get it as soon as possible and save cost. After all the payment will only commence later part.
* The correct index should not be inflation because from what I read, property price is increasing at the higher rate. But since I can’t find the correct index, we’ll stick with this for a conservative calculation.
b. Eligibility of Housing Grants.
Based on the HDB website, the government extends housing grant of up to $35,000 (3 room flat in new estates) to first time applicants who have a combine average gross monthly income of $5,000 or less, which we should be able to qualify now. In the same scenario of purchasing a flat 3 years later, we might face a possibility of not being able to meet the requirement of the grant, i.e, the income ceiling of $5,000. Of course I’m not saying that I’m very confident that we’ll hit the ceiling, but I guess everyone hopes to make as much money as they can. Base on my conservative calculations, if C earns about $2.5k a month as a degree holder and I earn a pay of about $2k as a dip holder. Our combined monthly income is about $4.5k excluding 13th month, variable bonuses. commissions and other possible sources of income.
The point here is that the later we purchase, the higher the possibility that we will need to fork out more (at least another $35,000 if we don’t qualify for the grant) as we earn more the longer we are in the workforce.
c. Temporary Housing.
Assuming if we settle down 3 years later and then decides to purchase a BTO flat, we will need to rent a room until we get our apartment, say 3 years later. The rental for me now is about $570. For the purpose of simplicity, we use $570 a month, ignoring inflation. $570 x 36 months works out to be $20,520. This could have been additional cost savings if we purchase a flat now a have it 3 years later instead of 6 years later.
The point here is that we should try to minimize the time inbetween not paying for our own accomodation till the point of time we are actually paying our installment instead of paying rent.
d. Possible growth of population resulting in increase in property prices.
Inflation aside. Singapore will see an increase in population over the years from the current 5.18 million to God-knows-how-much-people they are importing. Base on supply and demand, if demand is high, supply is low, price increase. How much it more will increase, we do not know. I’m putting a conservative figure of $10,000 more.
The point here is that land size has stopped increasing while population is always increasing resulting in more expensive property. The earlier we buy, we more we minimize the effect of overcrowding.
e. Smaller area of flat.
Over the years, as population increases and land size remains unchanged, the size of the flat is becoming smaller over the years. When I was staying in pasir ris about 15 years ago, 4 room flat was about 110 sqm, now 4 room flat is about 87sqm. So there will be a possibility where the BTO flat in which we will purchase 3 years later that will be designed to meet the needs of 6 years later will be smaller yet more expensive. Which means the cost per square metre is higher. In which case will indirectly affect the saleability and price of the flat when we sell to open market later. People would rather purchase older apartment for bigger space if the price difference is not too much? I’m not sure how much more, but I’m putting a conservative figure of $10,000 more to this.
The point here is that every few years, the flats become smaller. The earlier we buy, the bigger the house we get for the same price later.
f. Possibility of improve in infrastructure.
Currently the estate is relatively new. No major shopping centres and relatively new transport network. Over the years as the estate becomes more developed, there will be better infrastructure such as better transport network resulting in shorter time taken to travel to city and a shopping centre that has all the entertainment facilities. This is also add on to the cost of purchasing a flat later on. +$10,000.
The point here is that we should try to buy before the estate is developed. Once it is developed, it will cost more.
g. Availability of BTO choices 3 years later.
What is available now may not be available later on. 3 years later, we may end up with choices that we don’t prefer, such as Choa Chu Kang, Yew Tee, Jurong, i.e the west side. If we so choose not to purchase those flats, we will have to 1. continue paying rental while waiting. 2. purchase from open market. +$10,000
The point here is the uncertainty of choices later on. We may not get what we want after 3 years resulting in a longer wait -> pay more rent for a house that does not belong to us.
h. Uncertainty of future resulting in short term plan costing more money.
Without a long term plan, we will require many interim plans until such time we have a long term plan in place. During this interim period, we may be making unneccessary moves which will cost us money for e.g moving from place to place as a result of bad rental relationships, which is absolutely possible. or adjustments due to unforseen circumstances. +$5,000
The point is to try to have certainty to reduce cost incurred due to uncertainty.
i. Possible changes in government/housing policy.
We can not be sure that the policy will be the same after 3 years. Whether is it more favourable or less favourable, we can not be certain. +$5,000
There maybe other factors that I have missed out. Based on all this probable scenarios, we are looking at a possible difference of about $120,000 to $150,000 lost of cost savings if we choose to purchase BTO 3 years later, the additional cost from the point of purchase till the possible loss of profits when selling it back to open market.
The point here is that the more we save when buying, the more we will make when selling it, i.e when the market is good.
- This is just a rough sketch of ideas that I have come up with for my own reference. Along the way there may be new findings that will cause some of the points to become irrelavent.
Update:
After calling up HDB, I realised that the grant will only be extended if either or both parties have been working for at least 1 year. So the earliest we can embark on it is June 2013…








